Back to Top
Because
News
Matters

Rikers Island to Close by 2032: What Mamdani Wants to Change About New York's Jail System

Mamdani New York Jail Closure: New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani wants to close the notorious Rikers Island jail by 2032, replace it with four smaller facilities and reduce the city's detainee population. But can the plan change how the city approaches pre-trial detention, mental health and criminal justice?

Mamdani New York Jail Closure
Mamdani's Rikers Island Closure Plan: Can New York Rethink Its Approach to Detention? | Courtesy: X/Zohran Mamdani

Mamdani New York Jail Closure: For decades, New York City's Rikers Island jail complex has come to represent some of the worst problems within the American prison system. Overcrowding, staff shortages, deteriorating infrastructure, violence and inmate deaths have repeatedly brought the facility under scrutiny. Now, the city is attempting to address a question that goes beyond the closure of a notorious jail: can it change the way people are detained in the first place?

Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Friday unveiled a revised plan to shut down Rikers Island by 2032, replacing the sprawling complex with four smaller jails across New York City's boroughs. However, the proposal is not limited to building new facilities. It also seeks to reduce the number of people held in detention, expand mental health services and create alternatives for those awaiting trial.

The distinction matters. Closing an old jail and constructing new ones may improve detention conditions, but it does not necessarily address the reasons so many people end up behind bars or remain there while their cases move through the legal system.

Beyond Replacing an Ageing Jail

Located on a 413-acre island between Queens and the Bronx, Rikers Island currently houses more than 6,500 people at any given time. Its isolation has also made access difficult for families, who can spend hours travelling to visit detainees. The facility has acquired deeply troubling nicknames, including 'Gladiator School' and 'Torture Island', reflecting decades of criticism over its conditions. It has also faced scrutiny over inmate deaths, with nine reported this year, alongside allegations of violence, inadequate staffing and poor management.

Mamdani's proposal would replace the complex with four smaller facilities: one in Brooklyn by 2029, two in the Bronx and Queens by 2031, and another in Manhattan by 2032. The administration argues that smaller, more accessible jails can offer better living conditions, including access to daylight, fresh air and cleaner spaces. Their locations would also make it easier for families to visit detainees. However, the proposed facilities are only one part of the plan. The administration wants to reduce the city's jail population from more than 6,500 to approximately 4,100.

Why reducing the number of detainees matters

One of the most consequential aspects of the proposal is its attempt to reduce dependence on detention. A person held in jail is not necessarily someone who has been convicted of a crime. Many detainees are awaiting trial, with their cases yet to reach a final verdict. The length of time they spend in custody can depend on several factors, including bail requirements and delays in the legal process.

Mamdani's administration wants to address some of these issues by expanding alternatives to detention, making it easier for families to post bail online and speeding up pre-trial proceedings. It also plans to expand therapeutic housing for people with serious mental health conditions, rather than relying on conventional jail facilities to accommodate their needs.

The administration has already opened 100 therapeutic beds at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan, transferring 100 people from Rikers Island, according to Dana Kaplan, the official appointed to oversee the closure. The city has also proposed investing $146 million in mental health and substance use treatment, alongside vocational training and educational programmes inside and outside the new facilities.

The underlying idea is that detention should not become the default response to every person entering the criminal justice system, particularly when treatment or other forms of supervision may be more appropriate.

Public safety versus prison reform

The proposal, however, has already encountered resistance from the city's correction officers' union. The Correction Officers' Benevolent Association has criticised the proposed reduction in jail capacity, arguing that setting a limit of approximately 4,100 beds could compromise public safety. The union maintains that the city cannot achieve this target without releasing people facing violent felony charges irresponsibly.

Kaplan, however, disagrees with the criticism. She told the BBC that reducing the number of people held in New York City's jails was both possible and necessary. This disagreement highlights a larger challenge facing the administration: how to reduce incarceration without weakening public confidence in the criminal justice system. The question is not simply how many jail beds the city needs. It is also how decisions about detention are made, how long people remain in custody before trial and whether the system has sufficient alternatives for people who do not need to be held in conventional jail facilities.

A deadline that New York has already missed

The latest announcement also comes against the backdrop of years of delays. New York City's Council voted in 2019 to close Rikers Island, with the original plan setting 2026 as the target year. Legislation subsequently required the facility to close by 2027. However, logistical difficulties, disagreements over the locations of replacement jails and delays during the Covid pandemic pushed the timeline further.

Mamdani has also blamed delays under his predecessor, Eric Adams, for the failure to meet the earlier deadline. The problems at Rikers have become serious enough to attract federal intervention. Last year, a federal judge removed the jail complex from the city's direct control and appointed an independent official to oversee decisions concerning its operation.

In an 88-page report released on Friday, Mamdani described the facility as a product of deteriorating infrastructure and said the city had a moral imperative to close it. The revised proposal now requires approval from the New York City Council, although several members, including the Council speaker, have indicated their support.

Can closing Rikers become a turning point?

Dana Kaplan, whom Mamdani appointed as the city's 'Close Rikers Czar', has described the proposal as an opportunity to rethink detention rather than simply replace an ageing prison complex. Speaking to the BBC, she called it a generational opportunity to build a different kind of detention system and reconsider how people should be held.

That ambition is considerably larger than the physical closure of Rikers Island. The success of the plan will depend not only on whether four new facilities are completed on schedule, but also on whether the city can reduce unnecessary detention, improve access to treatment and ensure that people awaiting trial are not left in custody for prolonged periods.

For New York, the challenge is to demonstrate that a safer city and a less punitive detention system do not have to be competing goals. Rikers Island may eventually close, but the more important test will be whether the system that replaces it is meaningfully different.


Related News