Back to Top
Because
News
Matters

Political Rights Should Not Hinge on Fertility Rate

Two benches of the Supreme Court 23 years apart drew contradictory conclusions on the validity of two-child limit for contesting Panchayat elections. The problem is not with the disagreement but with the common reasoning which makes the validity of the electoral right contingent upon the fertility rate. The rise and fall in fertility rate will keep haunting candidates in fray until a larger bench delineates the contours of the political right to contest elections.

Fertility Rate and Electoral Rights
India's declining fertility rate has reopened the debate over the constitutional validity of the two-child norm and restrictions on the right to contest elections. [Representative Image] | Courtesy: Wikimedia Commons

Fertility Rate and Electoral Rights: In 2003, the Supreme Court upheld a bar on candidates with more than two children from contesting Panchayat elections. Twenty-three years later, the top court on November 4, 2026 drew a different conclusion taking note of a fall in the fertility rate in India. The final outcome of the two verdicts may be conflicting but the reasoning remains the same with both decisions primarily harping on demography to examine the validity of the law, rather than testing the law on the touchstone of the political right to contest elections in a democracy.

A bench of Justice P. S. Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe on November 4 referred the matter for review by a larger bench while expressing disagreement with the 2003 ruling in Javed V. State of Haryana which was decided when the total Fertility Rate was 3.0 as against the present rate of 1.9 which is below the replacement rate pegged at 2.1.

"Even if the law was legal and valid at the time of its making, it has become invalid as the foundation on which it rests has changed," the bench concluded in Mangala Bhimrao Ingle, while referring the matter to the Chief Justice for constitution of a larger bench in view of the divergent opinion by a three-judge bench in Javed. But for a few references to the political right of representation and impact on rights of women, Mangala Bhimrao Ingle focussed on the low fertility rate which could reverse the population growth.

A review of Javed was long overdue. Not for deciding if India still needs to control its population but for an authoritative pronouncement on the scope, ambit and status of the electoral rights of citizens. The population test would make the two-child norm valid once again if the fertility rate rises and invalid if the trend reverses.

It is not just the two-child norm. Relying on Javed, Rajbala V. State of Haryana (2025) upheld disqualification of candidates not having functional toilets at home, defaulting in payment of agriculture loan or electricity bill or for not possessing t=a prescribed minimum educational qualification. The demography test, therefore, justified testing the law against statistics on literacy, open defecation, defaults in payment of loans, electricity bills etc. This made the electoral right subject to the rise and fall in statistics.

Promoting literacy, hygiene etc. may be laudable but such social objectives should not be achieved at the cost of the political rights of those who are already lagging behind. 

The political right to contest election is a coveted right in a democracy. The judicial review of laws imposing such conditions and restrictions need to be tested on the contours of the right to contest elections. For this, an authoritative pronouncement is imperative to lay down the scope, ambit and status of the electoral right. It is on this touchstone that the rationale of any condition and restriction needs to be tested.

The challenge before the larger bench sought to be constituted would not be to settle if India still needs population control measures but to delineate the scope, ambit and status of the right to contest elections within our constitutional framework. 

A fresh look is necessary in view of several conflicting judicial pronouncements touching upon the subject. A six-judge bench in N.P. Ponnuswami (1952) stressed that the right to contest an election was a creature of statute. Jyoti Basu V. Debi Ghosal (1982) acknowledged the right to be fundamental to democracy but stressed that it was not a fundamental but a mere statutory right. A five-judge bench in Kuldip Nayar V. Union of India (2006) upheld the view in Jyoti Basu. The court, however, held in PUCL V. Union of India (2003) that the right to vote was “certainly a constitutional right”. In a five-judge judgment in Mohinder Singh Gill V. Chief Election Commissioner (1978), Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer observed that the right available to every Indian was “a constitutional as distinguished from a common law right”. The three-judge bench in Javed observed that it “may be said to be a constitutional right”. The Supreme Court specifically went into the question of the status of the right in Rajbala and held that both the right to vote and contest a Panchayat election are “constitutional rights” but went on to uphold sweeping restrictions on the right. The court observed it was necessary to decide the question “since the extent to which curtailment or regulation of such right is permissible depends upon the nature of the right”.

The status of a right, as averred in Rajbala, decides the rigor of judicial scrutiny. If it is a constitutional right flowing from the promise of our constitution, every condition or restriction would have to be justified under the scheme of the constitution. A bench of at least seven judges may be required to answer and settle the issue once for all in view of the observations by a six-judge bench in Ponnuswami and a five-judge bench in Kuldip Nayar.

No right can be looked at in isolation. The scheme of the democratic polity established by our Constitution cannot be overlooked while looking for an answer. The Preamble promises political justice to all while the fundamental rights to equality guarantee equal protection of law and equality of opportunity to all citizens. Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, as noted in Mangala Bhimrao Ingle, considered citizenship to be a bundle of rights which included the right to representation in the government.

Relying on statistics to decide the political rights of an individual would betray the wishes of our constitution-makers. The low literacy rate persuaded the Constituent Assembly against providing educational qualification for voters. "I a country where large mass of people are illiterate and the people owing property are few, the introduction of any property or educational qualifications for the exercise of franchise would be a negation of the principles of democracy," Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar said in the Constituent Assembly on November 23, 1949.

Political rights ensure that every citizen counts in a democracy. In his concluding speech in the Constituent Assembly on November 25, 1949, Dr. B. R. Ambedkar stressed that the constitution had built a structure of political democracy which recognized "the principle of one man, one vote and one vote, one value". The political right of a citizen to contest election, therefore, should be the starting point and the basis for testing the validity of ant restriction or eligibility condition imposed by law. There may be a nexus between a disqualification and the social objective sought to be achieved by it but such nexus cannot be said to be rational in the context of the right to contest elections.

The problem is not with the conflicting conclusions in Javed and Mangala Bhimrao Ingle but with the reasoning that makes the validity of the law contingent upon statistics. The fertility rate may keep rising and falling. Political rights cannot be ade to rise and fall with it.


Related News