Back to Top
Because
News
Matters

EXCLUSIVE: 83% of Gold Outlets in India Escape Surveillance for Hallmark Claim

A CAG audit has flagged major gaps in BIS market surveillance, finding that 83% of registered gold jewellery outlets did not undergo mandatory annual verification. The audit also reported a 43% shortfall in surveillance audits of hallmarking centres, raising questions about the monitoring of gold purity certification.

India Gold Hallmarking Surveillance Audit
A gold jewellery showroom displaying BIS-hallmarked ornaments. A CAG audit has flagged gaps in BIS surveillance of jewellers and hallmarking centres. [Representative Image] | Courtesy: Unsplash

India Gold Hallmarking Surveillance Audit: All that glitters is not gold. This age-old adage should be taken seriously by consumers as a recent audit by the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) has revealed that the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) failed to conduct the mandatory random verifications with respect to 83 per cent outlets selling hallmarked gold jewellery in the market. Sources said the audit had flagged non-achievement of market surveillance, which required at least one visit every year during the last five years for verifying claims of hallmarked purity by BIS-registered jewellers, which had risen from 30,000 in 2001 to 2.3 lakh at present.

Mandatory Hallmarking Covers 392 Districts

The Hallmarking of Gold Jewellery and Gold Artefacts Order notified by the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution in 2020 mandates sale of only hallmarked gold articles in notified districts, which now cover 392 districts after an amendment this year.

The compulsory hallmarking scheme was introduced by the government to boost consumer confidence, and over 65 crore gold articles have been hallmarked since July 1, 2001. The hallmarking is done by Assaying and Hallmarking Centres (AHCs) registered under the BIS.

43% Shortfall in Surveillance Audits of Hallmarking Centres

Sources said the BIS had also failed to undertake the mandated one annual surveillance audit of every AHC, which was entrusted with the task of testing purity and certifying it through hallmarking. The data shared with auditors reportedly revealed a shortfall of about 43 per cent in meeting the surveillance target for AHCs, sources said.

There is no corresponding rule mandating compulsory hallmarking of silver ornaments, but jewellers were voluntarily seeking hallmarks on silver items as consumers had bestowed faith in the system. So far, over 70 lakh silver articles had already been hallmarked since September 1, 2025, a source privy to the data said.

CAG Audit Flags Gaps in BIS Monitoring Mechanism

The data collected by auditors for preparing a report revealed that the monitoring mechanism for the market as well as for the AHCs had failed to meet the prescribed benchmark, despite the requirement of at least one visit every year.

Sources said the draft report by CAG had been sent for final comments to the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution in July 2026 and is expected to be tabled in Parliament after factoring in the ministry's response.

BIS Cites Staff Shortage, COVID-19 Disruptions

The auditors had sought the response of BIS, which cited lack of manpower for not carrying out surveillance to cross-check claims made by jewellers and certification by AHCs. It also pointed to difficulties faced on account of the COVID-19 outbreak. While the audit covered the period 2020-21 to 2024-25, BIS claimed that its surveillance targets were achieved during 2025-26.

Sources in the BIS said the regulator was using contractual employees for market surveillance of gold and silver jewellery outlets. This was a cause of concern as an important task of collecting samples from the market was outsourced to contractual employees designated as BIS Hallmarking Representatives, who were not governed by service rules, a source said on condition of anonymity.

Gaps in Surveillance Raise Concerns Over Gold Purity Verification

It may be noted that failure to meet the benchmark for market surveillance impacts the verification of the purity and fineness of gold articles available in the market and may be hurting the interests of consumers. Sources said there should be no compromise on surveillance as there were cases of adverse reports against several AHCs and jewellers.

 

Related News