Back to Top
Because
News
Matters

COP31 Drops Fossil Fuel Language, as India Wanted, and Climate Finance Goes with It

COP31 Outcome Climate Finance India: COP31's revised draft has dropped references to moving away from fossil fuels, aligning with India's position on energy transition. However, the removal of a proposed $120 billion annual adaptation-finance target has raised concerns over support for developing countries. What does the revised text mean for India's wider climate demands?

COP31 Outcome Climate Finance India
COP31 Outcome Climate Finance India: Delegates attend the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, amid negotiations over fossil fuel commitments, climate finance and the global energy transition. | Courtesy: Flickr

COP31 Outcome Climate Finance India: The latest draft agreement at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, has dropped references to moving away from fossil fuels. The change is in line with India's position that countries should decide their own timelines for reducing dependence on coal, oil and gas, based on their energy needs and development priorities. 

But fossil fuels are only one part of the negotiations. India and other developing countries have also been seeking greater financial support from wealthier nations to deal with climate change. The revised draft, however, has dropped some of the specific financial commitments proposed earlier. So, while the changes reflect one of India's demands, has the country made progress on the others?

Why India Opposed a Fossil Fuel Phase-Out

Ahead of COP31, Union Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav said India would not support a fossil fuel phase-out or a roadmap towards one, according to Hindustan Times. India's argument is that developing countries cannot be expected to move away from fossil fuels at the same pace as developed economies. Their energy requirements and development priorities are different. For India, the transition must also account for affordable and reliable energy, economic growth and poverty eradication.

Also Read: Kerala’s Cashew Plantation Disaster Cited by UN to Warn of Global Chemical Risks

The country's position is also based on the principle of Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC). It recognises that countries have contributed differently to climate change and have different capacities to address it. India argues that developed nations, which account for a larger share of historical emissions, should take the lead in cutting emissions and providing financial and technological support.

India's official COP31 priorities, outlined by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change on November 3, included predictable climate finance, technology transfer, adaptation funding and a just transition. It also called for countries to retain the freedom to set their own climate targets.

What Changed in the COP31 Draft?

The November 16 draft had proposed accelerating action to phase out fossil fuels and included references to roadmaps for the transition away from fossil fuels and deforestation. The revised draft, released on November 19, removed these references, including the commitment made at COP28 in Dubai in 2023 to transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. But there was another significant change. The earlier draft had proposed $120 billion in annual adaptation finance by 2035 for developing countries. The revised version dropped this specific figure, although it retained a call to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035.

Also Read: Ladakh's Democracy Gap: How Traditional Village Leadership Filled Part of the Void

The revised draft also retained a proposal to increase electricity's share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035. However, this was listed as an area for possible cooperation rather than a binding target for every country. Down To Earth's analysis reported that India and the Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDC), which includes China, Egypt and Saudi Arabia, had opposed new top-down targets without adequate financial support and flexibility.

What Does India Gain?

The removal of fossil fuel language is consistent with India's position. However, the revised draft does not necessarily advance its wider negotiating agenda. India had sought stronger commitments on climate finance, adaptation and technology transfer. The removal of the proposed $120 billion adaptation-finance figure raises questions about whether developing countries will receive the support they need to prepare for climate-related risks.

India has also called on developed countries to meet their obligations under Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement, which requires them to provide financial resources to developing countries for climate action. Trade measures are another concern. India has opposed unilateral measures that could affect developing countries' exports, including the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).

The first COP31 draft had called for developed countries to phase out unilateral trade measures with negative cross-border impacts by 2027. The revised version dropped that deadline and instead referred to concerns about such measures. In other words, the removal of fossil fuel language may be a gain for India, but its demands on finance and trade remain unresolved. India has not formally commented on the revised draft as of November 20.

India's Energy Needs and the Transition Debate

India's position is closely linked to its dependence on fossil fuels. Coal remains a major source of electricity and supports industries that require reliable power. Reducing its use would require substantial investment in renewable energy, electricity storage and transmission infrastructure. India has expanded its renewable energy capacity, but it also faces rising electricity demand. The challenge is to meet that demand while keeping energy affordable and reliable.

This is also relevant to the proposed global target of increasing electricity's share of final energy consumption to 35% by 2035. Former Indian climate negotiator Ajay Mathur told Hindustan Times that the target would be ambitious for India. He estimated that the country's share could reach 32-34% by 2035.

COP31 Talks Enter Overtime

The revised draft has not resolved the differences between countries. As of November 21, negotiations had continued beyond the summit's scheduled closing date. The removal of fossil fuel references had drawn criticism from activists and some countries, while climate-vulnerable nations continued to demand greater financial support from wealthier economies.

For India, the final outcome will involve more than whether the agreement avoids a uniform commitment to move away from fossil fuels. It will also depend on progress on climate finance, technology transfer and the freedom to determine national energy policies.  


Related News