Back to Top
Because
News
Matters

CAG Audit Finds BIS Lax on Grievance Redressal and Legal Action; 62% of Complaints Delayed

India Gold Hallmarking Surveillance Audit:

India Gold Hallmarking Surveillance Audit
India Gold Hallmarking Surveillance Audit: CAG audit finds BIS delayed 62% of consumer complaints over ISI-marked goods and hallmarked jewellery, while flagging gaps in enforcement and legal action. [Representative Image] | Courtesy: Pixabay

Delayed Grievance Redressal by BIS: The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) reportedly failed to dispose of 62 per cent complaints received from consumers during the last five years against ISI-marked goods and hallmarked jewellery within the stipulated time-frame. Sources said an audit of the records by the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) revealed that BIS failed to decide 1,515 of the 2,450 complaints within the time-limit stipulated its own Citizen’s Charter framed in 2020 and Circular dated 5.06.2023. The complaints are to be decided within 90 days or 120 days if a test was necessary.

On comments being sought by the auditors, BIS submitted that corrective measures had been initiated to address the gaps. In case of gold jewellery, a complaint is either against a jeweller or against an Assaying and Hallmarking Centre (AHC) which is entrusted with the task of testing and hallmarking gold.

Informed sources told The Slate that timely consideration of complaints is crucial as the Bureau of Indian Standards (Hallmarking) Regulations, 2018 provide for restraint on hallmarking by an Assaying and Hallmarking Centre (AHC) and cancellation of recognition in case a serious violation is detected. The guidelines provide for according top priority to enforcement, they said.

The auditors also found serious lapses in enforcement, sources said, while adding that no consolidated records were maintained at the higher level with regard to enforcement activities undertaken by branch offices, lapses detected against jewellers and AHCs or with regard to prosecution and penalty proceedings, sources said.

The auditors also found serious lapses in pursuing court cases against shopkeepers selling products with spurious marking, sources said. In one case, a criminal complaint filed by BIS was quashed after 11 years in 2023 on the ground of non-appearance of complainant, a source aware of the case said. The perusal of the records by auditors revealed that a revision petition was filed against the said order in 2025 but the same was dismissed on the ground of delay in filing review without sufficient cause.

Sources said the draft report by CAG had been sent for final comments to the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution in July 2026 and is expected to be tabled in Parliament after factoring in the response of the ministry.


Related News