Why Is India Afraid of Letting Private FM Radio Tell the News?
A blanket ban on news and current affairs on private FM radio is increasingly difficult to reconcile with constitutional freedoms. India needs regulation, not censorship, of the airwaves.
Private FM Radio News Ban: More than twenty-five years after private FM radio was introduced in India, the medium remains strangely confined when it comes to matters of public interest. A radio station can tell its listeners that a road is congested, that the monsoon has arrived, or that examination results have been declared. But it cannot explain why a bridge has collapsed, discuss a decision taken by the municipal corporation, analyse a government policy, or interview a local elected representative about an issue affecting the lives of its listeners. In a country that constitutionally guarantees freedom of speech and expression, this is an extraordinary restriction.
Private FM stations are permitted to broadcast All India Radio news bulletins, provided they reproduce them without alteration. They cannot independently gather, produce or broadcast news. Equally significant is the prohibition on current affairs, which prevents radio presenters from discussing and analysing developments in public life. The distinction matters. A ban on news stops the bulletin; a ban on current affairs stops the conversation.
Radio is perhaps the most immediate and accessible medium of mass communication. It accompanies people while travelling, working, running businesses and going about their daily lives. Its local character makes it particularly valuable in a country as diverse as India. Yet, while newspapers, television channels and digital news platforms can report on public affairs, private FM radio remains excluded from this important democratic function.
The question is no longer whether private FM radio should be permitted to broadcast news. The more fundamental question is whether the continuing prohibition can be constitutionally justified.
The Constitutional Promise of Freedom of Expression
The starting point must be Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution, which guarantees every citizen the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression. The Supreme Court, in Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting v. Cricket Association of Bengal (1995), made it clear that broadcasting is an integral part of this freedom. The Court recognised that airwaves are public property and must be utilised for the public good, ensuring plurality of views and the right of citizens to receive information.
This judgment has significance beyond the rights of broadcasters. Freedom of expression is not merely the right to speak; it also includes the right of citizens to receive information. Consequently, the issue is not confined to the commercial interests of private FM operators. It concerns the information rights of millions of listeners who depend on radio as a source of communication and public engagement.
Article 19(2) permits reasonable restrictions on freedom of speech and expression on specified grounds, including sovereignty and integrity of India, security of the State, public order, decency, morality, defamation and incitement to an offence. Significantly, the mere broadcasting of news or discussion of current affairs is not an independent ground for restricting speech under Article 19(2).
The State certainly has the authority to regulate broadcasting and act against content that violates the law. However, regulation of content and a blanket prohibition on an entire category of expression are constitutionally different propositions.
Why Should Radio be Treated Differently?
The inconsistency becomes particularly apparent when one compares the treatment of different forms of media in India. Newspapers can publish news and editorial commentary. Private television channels can broadcast news and conduct debates on matters of public importance. Digital news publishers can report on political, social and economic developments, subject to applicable laws and regulatory requirements. All India Radio itself broadcasts news.
Yet a private FM station operating in the same city, serving the same population and often belonging to the same media group, cannot independently report the very developments that its newspaper, television channel or digital platform is permitted to cover. There is no obvious constitutional justification for this distinction.
International practice also provides a useful perspective. Private and commercial radio broadcasters in the United Kingdom, United States, Canada, Australia, Germany, France, Japan and several other democracies are permitted to broadcast their own news, subject to applicable regulatory frameworks. Our neighbours, including Nepal, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh, also permit private radio stations to carry news.
These countries recognise an important principle: the possibility of misuse of a medium is a reason to regulate it responsibly, not necessarily to prohibit it altogether. India should be able to adopt the same approach.
The Government's Concerns do not Justify a Blanket Ban
The principal concerns historically raised by the Government have related to monitoring, national security and the possibility of misinformation or misuse by private broadcasters. These concerns deserve serious consideration. Broadcasting has the potential to influence public opinion, and irresponsible reporting can create problems, particularly in sensitive border areas or during communal disturbances and emergencies. However, these are questions of regulation, supervision and accountability.
India already regulates television news channels, newspapers and digital publishers through different legal and regulatory frameworks. Private FM stations, too, operate under licence conditions and are subject to the applicable Programme and Advertising Codes. A broadcaster that violates the law can face regulatory consequences. In a genuine emergency, the State possesses powers to intervene. There is, therefore, no reason why a carefully designed regulatory framework cannot be applied to private FM news.
Indeed, a licensed FM station has an identifiable owner, a defined operating permission and a regulatory framework governing its functioning. It is difficult to understand why such a broadcaster should be considered inherently less capable of responsible reporting than an unverified source circulating information through social media or messaging applications. At a time when rumours and misinformation can spread rapidly through unregulated digital networks, credible local broadcasting could actually strengthen the quality of public information.
The Proportionality Test and the Constitutional Problem
The constitutional objection to the prohibition becomes stronger when examined against the doctrine of proportionality. The Supreme Court has developed this principle through several important decisions, including Modern Dental College v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2016), K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017) and Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India (2020).
The essential question is whether a restriction imposed by the State pursues a legitimate objective, whether the restriction is suitable to achieve that objective, whether a less restrictive alternative is available, and whether the harm caused to fundamental rights is justified by the public benefit. A blanket prohibition on private FM news faces considerable difficulty under this test.
If the concern is misinformation, a programme code, penalties and post-broadcast accountability are possible alternatives. If the concern is national security, narrowly tailored restrictions can be imposed in specific circumstances. If the concern is monitoring, appropriate compliance and regulatory mechanisms can be established.
Why, then, should every private FM station across the country be prohibited from broadcasting news and current affairs?
The absence of a clear definition of "current affairs" creates another constitutional difficulty. When broadcasters cannot confidently determine what they are prohibited from discussing, the result is a chilling effect on lawful speech. The Supreme Court's decision in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), which struck down Section 66A of the Information Technology Act, underlined the constitutional importance of certainty and clarity in restrictions affecting freedom of expression.
There is also a question about the legal foundation of the prohibition. The restriction operates through policy guidelines and licence conditions. Whether such executive and licensing provisions satisfy the constitutional requirement under Article 19(2) is an issue that merits judicial examination.
Nor can the Government simply argue that operators voluntarily accepted the restrictions when obtaining their licences. In Basheshar Nath v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1959), the Supreme Court recognised that fundamental rights cannot be waived. A condition imposed by the State does not become constitutionally immune merely because an operator has accepted it to enter the broadcasting business. More importantly, the listeners whose right to receive information is affected never consented to this restriction.
The Common Cause Case: An Unresolved Constitutional Question
The issue is already before the Supreme Court in Common Cause v. Union of India, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 880 of 2013. The petition, filed under Article 32 of the Constitution on 6 September 2013, challenged the restrictions preventing private FM and community radio stations from broadcasting news and current affairs. On 17 October 2013, a Supreme Court Bench headed by the then Chief Justice of India, Justice P. Sathasivam, issued notice to the Union Government.
In February 2017, the Government informed the Court about revised guidelines permitting private FM stations to carry All India Radio bulletins. The Court, however, indicated that the Government should consider permitting news and current affairs already available in the public domain, including material published by licensed private print and electronic media.
The petition was subsequently dismissed on a technical ground in April 2018. An application for restoration was filed, and, according to the petitioning organisation, the matter was restored. The constitutional questions have not been adjudicated on their merits. The case raises important questions concerning Article 19(1)(a), Article 14, the right to receive information, the proportionality of restrictions and the constitutional status of licensing conditions. These questions deserve a final and authoritative determination.
The Regulator has Already Indicated the Way Forward
There is now an opportunity to resolve the issue without waiting indefinitely for judicial intervention. On 23 September 2025, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India recommended that private FM broadcasters be permitted to broadcast up to ten minutes of news per hour under the applicable Programme Code. This is a significant development. It demonstrates that the concerns surrounding private FM news can be addressed through a regulated framework rather than an outright prohibition.
The Association of Radio Operators for India has also made representations to the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, TRAI and NITI Aayog seeking permission for private FM broadcasters to carry news and current affairs. The next step is for the Government to act on the regulator's recommendation.
The permission should extend to existing licensees rather than being restricted to future auctions. It should also cover current affairs, not merely the reading of news bulletins. A framework limited to short news bulletins would leave the central problem unresolved: the inability of radio to facilitate informed public discussion.
A phased introduction, beginning with local news and subject to clear programme standards, monitoring mechanisms and an effective complaints framework, would be a practical and responsible way forward.
Let Radio Become Part of India's Democratic Conversation
Radio is not merely an entertainment medium. It is a powerful instrument of public communication, particularly in smaller cities, towns and regions where local information has immediate relevance. Imagine a listener in a district town being able to hear a discussion on the local administration's response to flooding, an interview with the district collector on public health, or an informed debate on a government scheme affecting farmers and small businesses.
These are not inherently dangerous activities. They are precisely the kinds of public conversations that a healthy democracy should encourage. The argument for allowing private FM news is not an argument for unregulated broadcasting. It is an argument for responsible broadcasting under a clear and enforceable legal framework.
The State must retain the authority to act against unlawful content. Broadcasters must be accountable for accuracy, fairness and compliance with the law. But citizens should not be deprived of an entire medium of public information merely because the medium could potentially be misused. The Constitution does not guarantee freedom of expression only to newspapers, television channels or digital platforms. Nor does the right to receive information depend on the technology through which that information is delivered.
India has an opportunity to move beyond a policy inherited from an earlier era of broadcasting and recognise the role that private FM radio can play in a modern democracy. The airwaves belong to the public. Their use must serve the public interest. It is time that private FM radio is allowed to do what responsible media everywhere are expected to do: inform, question, analyse and participate in the democratic conversation.
The choice before the Government is simple: regulate the voice, but do not silence it.
Abhishek Rai is a regular face on television debates and practises before the Supreme Court and various High Courts, handling matters spanning civil and criminal law, as well as other legal issues.